Want to make a second Innovator Founder Endorsement application?

An endorsement refusal letter tells you something is missing.

It doesn't really tell you what.

Most refused founders do the obvious thing next. They rewrite the plan.

The plan does matter. To be endorsed, you'll need a plan you wrote yourself that shows three things: the business suits you, customers want it, and every number can be checked. (I call those your Founder/Business Model Fit, the innovation in your idea, and the credibility of your evidence.) The thing is, a rewrite only fixes the third. If customers haven't shown they want it yet, no rewrite will make them. And if the business doesn't suit you, nothing in the plan can fix that.

So our Second Attempt programme is one road with three stages, and the plan is where it ends.

Your free read shows which stage you start at. Some founders start at the end. Then we talk on a free 30-minute call, and if I think I can help, I'll offer you a place. If I don't, I'll tell you why. I only take your money when I think the work can help.

Where does your road start?

The three questions are about your Founder/Business Model Fit, the innovation in your idea, and the credibility of your evidence, in the order you fix them. Answer honestly. The first "no" shows where you start. Every road ends with your plan.

This road is a tool. Try it.

  1. Choose how much time you have.
  2. Answer yes or no to each question. Start with question 1.
  3. Your first "no" lights up the stage where you start.

Nothing you choose here is saved or sent to me. Change your answers as often as you like.

  1. You were refused Innovator Founder endorsement

  2. First

    Free read of your letter, and a free 30-minute call

    I show you which sentences decided it, and we work out together where you start.

  3. Next
    How much time do you have?

    Bring the date from your adviser

    If you're in the UK on a visa, your immigration adviser can tell you the date your application must be in. Count back from it. I don't set that date or judge it. I only check whether the work fits.

    Choose one:

    Applying from outside the UK? Your adviser can still tell you how the timing works for you.

  4. Then ask
    Question 1 · Your Founder/Business Model Fit

    Is this the right business for you?

    Forget the visa for a moment. Would you choose to run this business, at the size it has to reach? And could you sell to these customers yourself?

    Choose your answer:

  5. No
    You start here Stage 1 · Fit check · 2 to 4 weeks

    Find a business you really want to run

    For a Founder/Business Model Fit problem.

    Two sessions. We do the sum, including the jobs the business has to pay for, and you talk to five customers.

    Reshaped business: go to question 2"Not this one": a good result

    A minimum of six months
  6. Yes to question 1
    Question 2 · The innovation in your idea

    Have customers shown they want your idea?

    Customers show it by what they do: they sign up, they start using it, they pay. Have yours? Honest conversations about their problem help too.

    Choose your answer:

  7. No
    You start here Stage 2 · Problem cycle · 12 weeks

    Test whether customers want it

    For an idea problem.

    Six sessions. Interviews, a demand test and a real offer, judged against numbers we agree first.

    Carry onChangeStop

    Most founders need a second cycle.

    A minimum of four months
  8. Yes to question 2
    Question 3 · The credibility of your evidence

    Is your evidence ready for an assessor?

    You have the evidence. But have you gathered it, organised it, and presented it so that it convinces? And do your plan, forecast and budget agree with each other?

    Choose your answer:

  9. No
    You start here Stage 3 · Evidence sprint · 2 to 8 weeks

    Write the plan, and make the proof checkable

    For a credibility problem.

    How long depends on the evidence you already have. Your documents made to agree, your evidence written down, warm contacts turned into commitments, and a defence test.

    A minimum of two months
  10. Yes to question 3
    Ready to decide your next step

    A business, and a plan you can defend

    When to apply, and where, depends on your visa. That's a question for a regulated immigration adviser.

Business coaching only. We don't give immigration advice, and nobody can promise endorsement. Assessment takes time too: Innovator International, for example, says up to 40 days.

Stage 1: The Founder/Business Model Fit check

Most founders choose an idea, write the plan, and only find out later whether they want to run the business. But the assessor looks at you as well as the plan. The Home Office guidance asks whether you have, or are developing, the skills, knowledge, experience and market awareness to run it. At interview, they test it.

Getting it wrong costs a lot. From outside the UK, the endorsement fee, the visa fee and three years of the health surcharge come to about £5,500 before you earn a penny. Spending that on the wrong business is like driving for three years to a town you don't want to live in.

So we start with a sum. Let's say you want the business to pay you £40,000 a year in three years. After costs, it might need to bring in £120,000. If each customer pays £50 a month, that's £600 a year each. So you need 200 customers. Now the hard question. Have you ever sold to even one of them?

Two sessions, over two to four weeks. Between them, you talk to five of the customers you'd be selling to. At the end, you'll either have a business you really want to run, and you go on to the problem cycle, or you'll decide this isn't your business. Both are good results. The bad result is finding out in three years.

Price: £600. That's less than the endorsement fee for one application, and it's the cheapest way not to spend £5,500 on the wrong business.

You’ll leave with a decision: this business, a reshaped one, or not this one.

If after two sessions you still can’t decide, the third session is on me.

Stage 2: The Problem/Solution Fit cycle

Writing a plan before you've talked to customers is like driving with a paper bag over your head. You might be going the right way. You can't tell.

And rewriting it doesn't take the bag off. An AI tool will now write a polished plan for about £79 a month, so assessors see polished plans every day. Polish doesn't tell them anything any more. What they look for is evidence that real customers want what you sell. Without it, every rewrite costs you again: £2,000 to £6,000 for a new plan, another £1,000 assessment fee, and months of waiting for the same letter.

So we take the bag off first. Before we start, we agree what success looks like, in numbers. For example: you offer your product to ten real customers, six say yes, and at least one pays a deposit. (Speak to your immigration adviser before you take money from anyone. Your visa may not allow it.) Then, over twelve weeks and six sessions, you talk to the customers you'll sell to, find out what they use today and why they'd change, and make them a real offer. I read your work between sessions and write back. I hold you to the numbers we agreed.

At the end, you get a written answer. It might say: "Six of ten said yes. Two paid deposits. Carry on, with this customer, at this price." Or it might say change, or stop. Either way, it's based on what customers did. It's all about what people do, not what they say.

If the answer is "carry on", you move to the evidence sprint, and the evidence you've just gathered goes into your plan. Most founders need a second cycle before they get there. I'm telling you now, so it's never a surprise.

Price: £2,500. That's about what a plan writer charges to rewrite the plan you already have, and you get evidence instead of a new document. The first four founders pay a founding price of £1,300. This version of the Problem/.Solution Fit cycle is new, and you'll be helping me shape it, with honest feedback and permission to learn from your results anonymously. After the first four, it's £2,500. A second cycle is £2,000.

This costs the most because it's the hardest part of starting a business. It's where most founders lose their months, and it's where my experience counts most.

You pay half to start: £1,250 (or £650 if you're one of the first four). Halfway, after session three, we look at what your customer conversations have shown. If they show the problem isn't real, we stop there. You get a written verdict, and you don't pay the second half. That's not a failure. Stopping early is a result, and it can save you a year. (This applies once you've done the conversations we agreed. The method only works if the conversations happen.)

After each piece of work you send me, you'll have my written feedback within three working days.

Stage 3: The evidence sprint, where you write the plan

Every road ends here. Some founders start here, because their read shows the idea isn't the problem: they have customers, or real interest, and the assessor simply scored what was on the page. Others arrive from the problem cycle with fresh evidence. Either way, this is where the evidence becomes a plan.

The usual move is to send nearly the same plan again, or pay someone to polish it. But polish doesn't fix the real problem. Picture a recipe where the shopping list says six eggs and the method uses four. Each page looks fine on its own. Together, they don't agree. Business plans are often like that: the forecast, the canvas and the budget tell three different stories. In 2022, I reviewed nine founders in one of my programmes. Five lost marks for exactly this. (I can't see the mistakes in my own writing either. That's what other people are for.)

Here's the kind of question an assessor asks. "Your forecast says 40 customers by month six. Where does 40 come from?" If your answer starts with "I think", the number isn't evidence yet.

In the sprint, you write the plan, and I don't. An assessor can tell, and you'll have to defend it. We write down your evidence so someone else can check it. We make the plan, forecast, canvas and budget agree. We turn warm contacts into written commitments. I score your plan in all six areas the assessor scores, from 0 to 6, and tell you what would raise each one. Then I play the assessor. I pick three numbers and ask where each one came from. If you can't answer, we've found it before an assessor does.

It takes two to eight weeks, depending on how much evidence you already have.

Price: £1,500. That's about the cost of one more assessment fee and a polish, and it fixes what the polish can't. If you come straight from the problem cycle, it's only £1,000, because I already know your business and your evidence.

If you can't answer for one of the three numbers in the defence test, you fix it, and we run that part of the test again at no extra cost.

If you're starting here, I'll ask you on our free 30-minute call to show me the evidence you already have: your customer list, the emails, the letters of interest, the sales. Have it ready to share on screen. If it's there, I'll offer you a place. If it isn't, that tells us both that the problem cycle is the right place to start, and that's fine. You won't have paid anything.

How long does it take, really?

The stage you start at sets the length of the work. After that, the endorsing body needs time to assess your application. Innovator International, for example, says its assessment usually takes up to 40 days.

If you're in the UK on a visa, check with your adviser how that time fits your situation, before you start.

Here are your options

Stage How long What you get at the end Price
Stage1. Fit check How long2 to 4 weeks What you get at the endA business you want to run (go on to stage 2), or an honest "not this one" Price£600
Stage2. Problem cycle How long12 weeks What you get at the endA clear answer: carry on (go on to stage 3), change or stop Price£2,500First four founders £1,300
Stage3. Evidence sprint How long2 to 8 weeks What you get at the endYour plan, written by you, where every number can be checked Price£1,500[£1,000] straight after stage 2

You only have access to each option if I offer you a place.

What I won't do

I won't write your plan. You'll have to explain every number in it at interview, and it's much easier to explain your own.

I won't promise endorsement. Nobody honest can.

I won't give immigration advice. That includes when to apply, which endorsing body to use, and whether to ask for a second assessment or make a new application. Please ask a regulated adviser. You can find one on the Immigration Advice Authority's Find an immigration adviser page, the Law Society's Find a Solicitor, or the Law Society of Scotland's Find a Solicitor.

If you're in the UK on a visa, check with your adviser that your visa lets you sell to customers or run a pilot, before you start.

Why us?

I'm James Shoemark, the CEO at The Startup Race, and we've been coaching founders around the UK since 2010.

Since 2019, 1,134 international founders joined our programmes. Every one had free access to LeanStack, Ash Maurya's toolkit for testing whether an idea works. 76 proved they were ready for our accelerator programme.

Some of the others were paying up to £10,000 a year, and they still didn't meet the standard. So I said no

In May 2022, we brought Ash Maurya himself to Dundee, Glasgow and Edinburgh to teach founders how to test an idea before building it. The Problem/Solution Fit cycle is built on that method, and on what we've learned from watching founders use it.

In May 2022, we brought Ash Maurya himself to Dundee, Glasgow and Edinburgh to teach founders how to test an idea before building it. The Problem/Soloution Fit cycle is built on that method, and on what we've learned from watching founders use it.

Questions

Do I have to send my letter first? Yes. The free read is how we both find out where you should start.

What if I think the read put me in the wrong place? Tell me why on our call. I'd rather argue about it before you pay than after.

Can I use AI to write my plan? Yes. But you'll have to explain it, so we make sure you can.

Can I cancel? Yes, within 14 days of paying. If you asked me to start sooner, you pay for the sessions we've already had.

Will you tell me when I'm ready to apply? I'll tell you whether, in my opinion, your evidence answers what the assessor said. When to apply depends on your visa, so that's for your adviser.

Ready when you are

It starts with your letter. Send it to me, and I'll show you what it really says, and where you should start. It's free, in writing, within 5 working days.

Whether you go further is up to you.

Already had your letter read?

Reply to the email it came in, and we'll book your free 30-minute call.

The Startup Race Ltd is not accepting new applicants for visa endorsement.

The Endorsement Readiness Programme is education and coaching. It is not an endorsement.

We are not regulated by the Immigration Advice Authority and we do not give immigration advice.

For advice about your visa or immigration status, please speak to a regulated immigration adviser or solicitor.

The Startup Race Ltd. Registered in Scotland, company number SC536976.

Registered office: Orchard Brae House, 30 Queensferry Road, Edinburgh, EH4 2HS.

© Copyright The Startup Race 2026 | Finding Neos Since 2016